Manly Apartment Windows: Who Pays for Future Repairs?
Check strata records and by-laws before buying a Manly apartment to confirm who pays for replacement window repairs and avoid unexpected bills after settlement.

An apartment’s replacement windows do not automatically become the lot owner's repair bill because a previous owner paid to install them. In NSW, windows are commonly treated as common property, but the strata plan, adopted common property memorandum, registered by-laws and approval records can change the position. A Manly buyer should establish who maintains each relevant component before exchanging contracts, rather than relying on the seller's description or an old installation invoice.
ELYMENT Insights | Property & Conveyancing | Manly, NSW | 16 November 2026
The New Windows May Look Like an Upgrade. Their Maintenance History Is More Important.
Replacement windows can improve an apartment's appearance, thermal performance, acoustic insulation and general comfort. In Manly, where apartment buildings range from older residential blocks to more contemporary developments, upgraded glazing can be an attractive feature when a property comes onto the market.
However, the installation itself does not settle the question of who pays when something eventually fails.
Imagine a buyer inspecting an apartment with recently installed double-glazed windows. The seller explains that the previous owner arranged the upgrade several years earlier. The frames appear well maintained, the glass is intact and the apartment feels quieter than neighbouring properties.
After settlement, a sealed glass unit fails, a frame develops a problem or the owners corporation schedules external building repairs requiring access around the windows.
The buyer now needs to establish whether the repair belongs to the lot owner or the owners corporation.
The original installation invoice may explain who paid for the work. It does not necessarily establish who inherited the ongoing maintenance obligation.
Three separate questions therefore matter:
- Was the replacement window installation properly authorised?
- What documents allocated responsibility for ongoing maintenance?
- Does that allocation apply to the current owner of the apartment?
These questions should be resolved through the property's strata documentation before the purchase becomes unconditional.
What NSW Strata Law Says About Window Repairs
The starting point is section 106 of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015.
It places a statutory obligation on an owners corporation to properly maintain and repair common property and to renew or replace fixtures and fittings that form part of common property.
The NSW Government's strata repairs and maintenance guidance specifically identifies windows and window locks among the items generally maintained by the owners corporation.
However, that is not the end of the analysis.
Section 106 is subject to certain arrangements under the Act, including an adopted common property memorandum, common property rights by-laws and by-laws made under section 108.
Consequently, a buyer should not assume that every window in every NSW apartment scheme carries the same maintenance arrangement.
When can maintenance responsibility be allocated to an apartment owner?
Section 108 deals with authorised changes to common property. Where an owner is authorised to alter common property, the relevant special resolution may specify whether ongoing maintenance belongs to the owners corporation or the individual owner.
Importantly, where the resolution allocates ongoing maintenance to the owner, that arrangement has no effect unless the owners corporation obtains the owner's written consent to the required by-law and makes that by-law.
The Act also provides for the relevant by-law to operate in relation to subsequent owners.
This distinction is particularly important when purchasing an apartment where a previous owner arranged the window replacement.
A buyer needs to establish whether the maintenance obligation was formally allocated and whether the documentation continues to apply to the lot.
A committee email, contractor invoice or informal understanding should not automatically be treated as equivalent to a properly authorised and documented maintenance arrangement.
The Three Documents That Can Determine Who Pays
For a Manly apartment purchase, the review should focus on three connected parts of the strata documentation rather than relying on the appearance of the windows.
1. The registered strata plan
The strata plan helps establish the boundaries between an individual lot and common property.
This matters because a window assembly can involve several different elements, including:
- External window frames.
- Glass panels and glazing units.
- Opening sashes and associated hardware.
- Window locks and safety devices.
- Seals, screens and associated fittings.
- Connections between the window assembly and the external building structure.
Not every component necessarily has the same maintenance classification.
The plan should be reviewed alongside any applicable common property memorandum and registered by-laws. A buyer should avoid assuming that the entire window assembly belongs to the apartment simply because it can only be accessed from inside the lot.
2. The registered by-laws
The by-laws are particularly important when previous owners have changed elements of the building.
Look for provisions that specifically address:
- Replacement of original windows.
- Installation of double or acoustic glazing.
- Changes to window frames or external appearance.
- Maintenance and replacement obligations.
- Responsibility for damage caused by the installation.
- Access requirements for future building maintenance.
Under section 141 of the NSW Act, changes to strata by-laws do not take effect until the required notification is lodged and recorded by the Registrar-General.
Therefore, the buyer should not rely solely on a draft by-law or a meeting minute mentioning a proposed change.
The actual registered wording and its application to the relevant lot must be established.
The NSW Government's strata by-law guidance explains how potential owners can obtain and review the applicable rules.
3. The original window replacement approval
The approval history provides another important part of the picture.
Ask for the documentation supporting the previous installation, including:
- The original application submitted to the owners corporation.
- The relevant meeting minutes and special resolution, where applicable.
- Approved plans and specifications.
- Any registered by-law dealing with maintenance responsibility.
- Contractor invoices and installation records.
- Relevant certification, warranties and compliance documents.
- Correspondence concerning defects or subsequent repairs.
The approval pathway depends on the nature, date and extent of the work. The fact that windows were replaced does not, by itself, establish which approval category applied.
NSW Government guidance distinguishes between minor and major renovations, including work involving glazing and alterations affecting the building's external appearance.
For that reason, buyers should have the actual installation history reviewed rather than assuming that an informal approval was sufficient.
Why an Installation Approval Does Not Automatically Answer the Repair Question
One of the more important distinctions in NSW strata property transactions is the difference between permission to undertake work and responsibility for maintaining the resulting installation.
Consider three possible situations.
Window replacement and maintenance responsibility
- Situation: Previous owner obtained approval for replacement windows.
- What the buyer needs to establish: Whether the approval also dealt with ongoing maintenance and whether the required by-law was made.
- Situation: A special resolution authorised work but did not allocate ongoing maintenance.
- What the buyer needs to establish: Whether the statutory default under section 108 applies to the particular work.
- Situation: A valid maintenance by-law allocated responsibility to the lot owner.
- What the buyer needs to establish: Whether the by-law remains in force and applies to the apartment being purchased.
This is where a detailed contract and strata review becomes valuable.
A buyer may discover that the previous owner was responsible for maintaining the replacement windows under an arrangement that continues to apply to subsequent owners.
Alternatively, the documents may show that the owners corporation retained responsibility for maintaining the relevant common property.
Neither outcome should be assumed without reviewing the actual records.
The Repair Scenarios That Could Change the Buyer's Future Costs
Window maintenance is not limited to replacing broken glass. Different types of failure can involve different components, contractors and repair requirements.
Failed double-glazed units
Double-glazed windows use sealed glass units to provide insulation. If the seal fails and moisture develops between the panes, the affected unit may require replacement.
The buyer should establish whether the responsibility covers the glass unit, the surrounding frame or both.
Damaged frames and opening mechanisms
Frames, hinges, rollers and locking mechanisms can deteriorate independently of the glass.
A maintenance arrangement that refers generally to windows may require closer interpretation to establish which individual components it covers.
Water ingress around window junctions
Water entering around a window may involve more than the glazing itself.
The source could relate to seals, frame connections, façade interfaces or another building element. Replacing the glass without identifying the underlying problem may not resolve the issue.
Building façade and external repair projects
A larger maintenance programme can create a different financial question.
If contractors need access to window frames or surrounding areas to complete façade repairs, the project may involve temporary removal, protection, reinstatement and making good.
The buyer should understand whether the relevant approval or by-law addresses these circumstances and who is responsible for associated costs.
For a coastal apartment building, the practical implications of external maintenance should also be considered when reviewing the building's repair history and planned works.
What the Strata Records Can Reveal Before Exchange
The contract and registered by-laws are only part of the investigation. Previous maintenance discussions can reveal whether the replacement windows have already generated problems.
Buyers should ask their conveyancer or strata inspector to examine the available records for:
- Previous complaints about water entering around the windows.
- Reports of damaged or deteriorating frames.
- Requests for window replacement or repairs.
- Disputes between lot owners and the owners corporation.
- Previous contractor inspections and recommendations.
- Proposed façade or external building maintenance.
- Special levies or expenditure connected with window repairs.
- Any unresolved approval or compliance issues.
The records should also be considered alongside the scheme's financial position and long-term maintenance planning.
Elyment has previously examined how missing or inconsistent strata records can delay a Sydney apartment purchase. Replacement window documentation presents another example of why a complete and traceable approval history matters.
Buyers should also consider the capital works plan before purchasing a Sydney apartment. It may identify anticipated external repairs, façade work or other building expenditure that could affect future ownership costs.
A capital works plan will not necessarily identify every individual window issue. It should therefore be considered alongside the minutes, maintenance correspondence and relevant technical reports.
How a Manly Buyer Should Review Replacement Windows Before Exchange
A structured review can prevent an attractive upgrade from becoming an unexpected maintenance dispute after settlement.
- Identify the original window arrangement. Establish whether the current windows are original building components or later replacements.
- Compare the installation with the strata plan. Identify the relevant lot boundaries and common property elements.
- Obtain the registered by-laws. Check for provisions dealing with the windows, alterations and ongoing maintenance.
- Trace the approval history. Request the original application, relevant resolutions, plans and associated correspondence.
- Confirm whether responsibility was formally allocated. Where an owner maintenance obligation is claimed, check the relevant statutory process, written consent and by-law.
- Review previous repair discussions. Look for evidence of recurring defects, unresolved complaints or upcoming external works.
- Obtain written clarification before exchange. Ask the conveyancer to identify who is responsible for the relevant components and flag any unresolved uncertainty.
This process is particularly important when the windows are a significant selling feature or when the buyer intends to undertake additional renovation work after settlement.
The same principle applies to other apartment building elements. Elyment's article on distinguishing private lot defects from common property repairs in NSW strata explores how the registered property boundaries and previous alterations can influence repair responsibility.
What Happens When the Documentation Is Incomplete?
Not every apartment will have a straightforward window replacement history.
Older buildings may have undergone several rounds of maintenance. Previous owners may have used different contractors, while strata management records may refer to work without containing the complete installation documentation.
In these circumstances, buyers should avoid treating the absence of paperwork as proof that the installation was approved or that the owner is responsible for future repairs.
Instead, further enquiries may be required through the seller, owners corporation, strata manager, relevant contractor or other available records.
Depending on the circumstances, the buyer may need to consider:
- Obtaining additional strata records.
- Requesting clarification of the applicable maintenance by-law.
- Having the window installation assessed by an appropriate building professional.
- Reviewing whether outstanding repairs have been discussed or budgeted.
- Seeking advice about contractual protections before exchange.
Where the missing information could materially affect the buyer's decision, the issue should be resolved or its uncertainty clearly understood before proceeding.
The Commercial Lesson: The Upgrade Is Only Part of the Asset
Property improvements are often presented as evidence of a better-maintained apartment. New windows, upgraded glazing and modern frames can make a property more appealing to prospective purchasers.
However, the value of an improvement should be assessed alongside its approval history, maintenance obligations and future repair requirements.
For buyers, the distinction is financial as well as legal. A maintenance obligation allocated to an individual lot can influence the cost of ownership. An owners corporation responsibility can still expose the buyer to shared building expenditure through ordinary levies or special contributions.
Neither arrangement automatically makes an apartment a poor purchase. What matters is understanding the obligation before the transaction proceeds.
In NSW strata transactions, a well-presented apartment should be assessed as part of the wider building and its legal arrangements. That means looking beyond the installation date and establishing what the documents say about the next repair.
Review the Property Before You Commit
ELYMENT PROPERTY SERVICES | NSW
Buying an apartment with previous alterations? Review the relevant strata documentation, maintenance obligations and renovation considerations before exchange. Get practical support with property reviews, compliance considerations and project planning.
ELYMENT PROPERTY SERVICES | NSW
Review the Property Before You Commit
Buying an apartment with replacement windows or previous alterations? Review strata documentation, maintenance responsibilities and renovation considerations before exchange.
Request ReviewRelevant next actions
Explore the ELYMENT service most closely connected to this article.